Sacred Lake AI policy

Sacred Lake AI policy

in

Hello everyone,

I guess it’s time to talk about generative AI lest people think I am some sort of time traveler from the 2010s and have simply not heard the news about our lord and saviour [insert this month’s AI product here].

But since it is a heavy subject, let me lighten the mood and start with a joke. This was said by my former coworker. I don’t know if they meant it as a joke, but it did register as one to me. What they said was something like:

You vegetarian for ethical, political, environmental, personal or health reasons?

And here’s another joke for you:

Are you against using AI in games?

Of course not, I love GOAP!

Okay, now that the fun part is over, time to talk about AI.

Asset generation

I will not use generative AI to create images, sounds, text or any other asset for my games. Any asset packs I use will also be free of AI, although that will probably get harder and harder to perfectly enforce since a lot of people have an incentive to lie about their use of AI.

I don’t think people really need an explanation for this one. But in case you yourself are a time traveler from the 2010s, there’s the built-in plagiarism, the legal risks, the shallow quality, and lack of control to name a few.

Disclaimer

This is about me and my games. I do not care if you use AI or not. I will avoid your products if you do, however. At least if you use it for asset generation. Code is a bit more complicated.

Code generation

I’ve split this into a separate category since this is more controversial and I have used LLMs like Opus to generate code professionally before. And I am willing to use them again for other people if I one day return to a software engineering day job.

But I will not be using code generation tools for my own projects.

The Joy of Clojure

The primary reason is that I like programming. I like thinking about systems and implementing them. I like refactoring a lot. I even enjoy debugging, sometimes.

If I didn’t like coding, I would just use an engine like Godot and be done with it. Most of game development is not actually coding. Unless you’re making some really cutting edge physics or simulation I guess.

Now I know that being able to choose your tools is a privileged position. If you are a software engineer whose full time job it is now to either read AI output or prompt it my heart goes out to you. And if you are support staff in a company whose engineers decided to stop reading the code my heart goes out to you too.

I do wish you would stop structuring your day to optimize your token window reset.

Cottagecore

The secondary reason is that I don’t really need the tools for this type of project, anyway. Programming output won’t really be the bottleneck here and the codebase is so small I can pretty much remember all of it.

There’s no tedious integrations or other boilerplate to generate either.

It’s simply not worth the potential efficiency gains to juggle token allowances, worry about leaks, maintain the harness and pay for subscription tokens for a one-man operation.

You may counter that I will be left behind, that no-one will buy my games. But that’s always been the risk. The vast majority of games do not make any profit.

If it doesn’t work out it doesn’t work out.

Some people also don’t make distinctions between asset and code generation and oppose all use of generative AI in games. Which I believe is a valid position, although I am not sure how much I agree.

Ozymandias

The tertiary reason is that I am not sure the tech can sustain dedicated game development. It’s already over a month since the latest model that was supposed to upend everything, Opus 5.5, was released and all we’ve seen so far is, pardon my English, demo porn and clones of small games.

If AI is so capable, why aren’t there more examples of good games made with it by now? I know it’s not a lack of effort or tokens. Or time. I’ve played some game jam games made in a week without AI that are more exciting and fun.

And why is it that now that people supposedly have the power to make whatever they want, they are now just remaking the same things that already exist?

Of course, some of this is subjective. Maybe you really like Vampire Survivors clone #543 but with AI generated graphics?

But for myself, I haven’t seen it handle a long-term project I would care about, let alone care about making. Meanwhile, human-made games, even solo-developed ones, are everywhere and everywhen.

Conclusion

More fun topics next time. I wanted to keep this on topic and relatively brief, so I didn’t touch on the doomerism and utopianism in the world today.

It’s okay to not ride the AI lightning every day. Remember that all the people who didn’t install Clawdbot are still here. Heck, I’d bet most people have never even heard about it.

Take care of yourself out there.

P.S. I think I am going to start linking to a post or video related to the topic at the end of these, and since I didn’t really talk about the artistic side, here’s a post about making something heavy.